Back Cover Photo

Back Cover Photo
The Winecoff Fire - Atlanta 1946

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Secret Crush

On his sixteenth birthday Bobby Sollenberger perished in The Winecoff fire

Many of the dusty roads in and out of Milner, Georgia were still unpaved when a bus left for Atlanta on Friday December 6, 1946. On board were four Youth Assembly delegates, aged 15 - 16, from Milner High School.



 

Dorothy “Dot” Freeman and Bobby Sollenberger were in the midst of a budding romance. They'd dated a few times in Milner. With them were Dot's dear friend, Eloise Duke, and Rudolph Ogilvie.


Eloise Duke


 

They were all on their way to a much-awaited gathering of students, from all across the state, in Georgia's State Capitol building. Excitement was in the air. Freedom was calling. New responsibilities and a glimpse into adulthood awaited them. For Bobby and Dot the weekend in Atlanta would be made even better amid a swelling crush.

Upon arrival, a fateful mix-up in hotel reservations fractured the Milner delegation. The boys, Bobby and Rudolph, were left to find their own accommodations. They found them at the Winecoff Hotel. Room 1126.

At the Winecoff, Friday night went well for Rudolph. He socialized with other Youth Assembly delegates, including girls from Thomaston and Gainesville, Georgia. But Bobby, now separated from Dot, was ready to go home, but no means were available.

During the night Dot and Eloise were awakened by the wailing sirens of fire trucks - going elsewhere. Sounds of the big city, they concluded. Safely tucked away, they fell back to sleep.

In the Winecoff Hotel it was a vastly different story. Bobby and Rudolph were awakened by frightful screams and the acrid smell of smoke. They lifted their window on the hotel's back side and gazed down into the alleyway below.

Black smoke was rising and other guests were at their windows gasping for air. Breathing became difficult. Bobby wet some towels. Bobby considered jumping. Rudolph was opposed. He argued their best hope would be up the stairwell, to the hotel's roof. He started for the door. He tripped, recovered and felt his way toward the door. He called back to Bobby, over and over, but heard nothing.

Spots on the hallway's carpet were already burning. Rudolph bolted for the stairway. But smoke quickly sapped his strength. He ascended only one floor, finally crawling. He fell against a door and into a 12th floor room, also on the hotel's back side. He tripped over a woman's body and a man's voice asked, “did you close the door?” Rudolph gasped, “no”. The voice said, “oh, hell”. Then Rudolph passed out.

He was later rescued, still unconscious, across the alleyway on a fireman's ladder into an adjacent building. Bobby Sollenberger's charred remains were recovered hours later. When Rudolph Ogilvie finally awoke in Grady Hospital, a red-headed nurse was giving him a bath.

Saturday morning for Dot and Eloise began with an insistent knock on their hotel room door. A faculty adviser told them the delegation was going home and to ready themselves for a quick departure. It was obvious to the girls something bad had happened.

Amid much confusion, they were drawn to the fire scene. They saw the fire trucks, the dangling sheet ropes, the tangled hoses, the water and debris everywhere, the ambulances – and the covered stretchers.

They learned Bobby was missing and Rudolph was in Grady Hospital and wouldn't be going home anytime soon. Imagine their disillusionment. What was to have been a new and exciting experience turned out to be a complete tragedy. One that would worsen - and last.

_____________

After high school Dot Freeman went to work in Griffin, Georgia's textile mills. She married Robert Jones, a man six years her senior, in 1949.

Robert Jones and his new bride, Dorothy "Dot" Freeman Jones

They had a son, Russ, in 1956.
Russ Jones, 12

When Russ was twelve years old a couple moved into the house across the street from the Jones's. Dot told Russ that the couple's only son had been her classmate, Bobby Sollenberger, who'd died in the Winecoff fire. A curious coincidence, Russ assumed.

_____________

Robert Jones passed away in 2008. By 2023, Dot's health was failing and she knew her end was near. Their son, Russ, cared for her during her final six months. Long hours together yielded tidbits about her life. Things Russ never knew and never thought to ask.

Slowly it became clear the shocks of the Winecoff fire had affected her much more than she'd ever revealed to him – or his father.

One revelation that stunned Russ was that she and Eloise had long suspected a local man, a known bootlegger, of intentionally setting the Winecoff fire. Russ was able to accept her suspicion as just that, a fascinating suspicion.

What he didn't know was the Winecoff fire, after seventy-seven years, had a special shock waiting just for him. Dot confessed to her son she'd never gotten over her crush on Bobby Sollenberger and had kept it a secret from both he and his father.

What good would it have done to tell them? It would only have undermined her marriage and confused her son.

Dot's 2023 confession made Russ rethink the coincidence that brought the Solleberger couple to his street. Had they moved there intentionally? Had Bobby expressed his feelings for Dot to them? Had they wanted to be near the girl Bobby was dating when he'd perished?

Did they sense he still lived in her heart? Were they aware of her secret crush?

Why did Dot tell her son about her crush in 2023? It did confuse him. Did she want him to see his dad as only second best? Probably not, he concluded. He could only assume she wanted the fact more widely known – eventually.

Editor's note: Many thanks to Russ Jones, 73, for sharing his mother's story with winecoff.org in 2026.

Wednesday, December 7, 2022

Family Mystery Resolved

Sara Willis Parker (center left) welcomed Jane Alfandre (left), Mary Jane Ruth Webb (center right) and Ashley Webb (right) into her home in 2022. Behind them are portraits of Sara and the sister she lost in the 1946 Winecoff fire, Maxine Willis.

When Ashley Webb was growing up in metro Atlanta, she knew that her grandmother’s younger sister—16-year-old Ruth Powell of Bainbridge, Georgia—had been killed as a teenager. Like so many relatives of Winecoff Hotel fire victims, Ashley didn’t know much else.   

“Growing up, I knew Ruth existed but no one would ever talk about her,” Ashley said. “I guess it was instinctively in me never to ask my grandmother.”

Ashley eventually learned Ruth, her great aunt, was killed in hotel fire in Atlanta but even those details were murky. “I was always told she was there on a church choir trip,” Ashley said.

Despite naming her daughter after Ruth a dozen years ago, Ashley did not see a picture of Ruth until after her grandmother passed away a couple of years ago. “That’s how much we did not talk about her,” she said.

Ruth’s picture was in a batch of old photos her grandfather passed on to Ashley. When she came across a picture of someone she could not identify, she asked her aunt who it was. “Oh, that’s Ruth,” her aunt replied,

With Ruth now alive in her mind, Ashley started looking for information about the Winecoff Fire. When she discovered www.winecoff.org, she contacted its editor, Allen Goodwin, co-author of The Winecoff Fire.

“When Allen said he could put me in touch with someone who knew Ruth, it just brought tears to my eyes, that there was someone out there who still remembered her,” Ashley said.

In October 2022 Ashley traveled with her mother and daughter to meet Sara Willis Parker, the person Allen had in mind. Sara’s younger sister, Maxine Willis, and Ruth Powell were best friends. They were also roommates on December 7, 1946 in Room 920 at the Winecoff Hotel.

They were two of the seven YMCA Youth Assembly delegates and one faculty adviser from Bainbridge High School killed in the fire, all staying in rooms on the back side of the ninth floor, where there was no means of escape. “We lost eight people and we were such a small town,” Sara said.

Three days after the fire, a joint funeral for Ruth and Maxine was held at Bainbridge Baptist Church.

Sara was only 14 months older than her 16-year-old sister Maxine and was with Maxine and Ruth so much that Maxine’s mother called them “The Three Musketeers.”

“We were always together growing up, the three of us,” Sara said. “We were so close in age that I was with Ruth about half the time Maxine was, and I really got to know her so well. She was such a precious person. She was the sweetest, funniest, and always in the best mood. And fun.”

Ruth Powell (center right) and Maxine Willis (right) died in the Winecoff fire

“I don’t want her (Ruth) to be forgotten,” Ashley told Sara. “I don’t want her to be just a name. I want her, and her memory, to live on. I named my daughter after her.”

When Ashley told her grandmother, Lori Powell, that she was naming her daughter after Ruth, she was surprised by Lori’s reply. “She said, ‘Well, that’s nice,’ and that’s all she said,” recalled Ashley.

Lori’s unemotional response was a product of how many Americans handled overwhelming grief at the time of the Winecoff fire. Family members either chose not to talk about tragedy or were discouraged from doing so by others – with common messages being “just try to forget it” or “it’s best not to talk about it.”

Sara knew Ruth’s mother, Cleata Powell, and described her as being “very stoic and showing no emotion.” That was the best way Cleata knew to cope with her pain, and Lori, her daughter, apparently adopted the same approach to Ruth’s death. As a result, Lori did not talk about Ruth’s death with her own children, perhaps not to scar them. Such an approach was not unusual within the families of Winecoff victims, but it left Ashley’s own mother not able to answer Ashley’s questions about Ruth.

Like many people, Ashley began to look inward as she grew into adulthood and started her own family. “I have become very in tune to where I came from, who I am, who came before me, and a big part of that is Ruth. So I have been on a journey to find out who she was,” said Ashley.

Saturday, October 23, 2021

Goodson Family Photographs Discovered

Here are photos of the Goodson family, circa 1943 - newly discovered by Winecoff Fire reader, Cheryl Pampe Fowler. She tells the story of the photos, kept safe for seventy-five years, in her Readers' Mail item.

The Goodson's tragic story is told on pages 51, 52 and 226 of the hardback edition of The Winecoff Fire: The Untold Story of America's Deadliest Hotel Fire.

The Goodson home in Clay City, Ill.


Living room where Cheryl Pampe Fowler later lived and played.

The home was on Pure Oil Company land.

Joe Goodson. a Pure Oil geologist and his wife, Galdys

Joe Goodson Jr. and son, Joe III

Gladys Goodson and Joe III


Cheryl Pampe Fowler and brother, Carl William Pampe.  
The Pampe family moved into the Goodsons' Clay City home in the weeks following the Winecoff fire.

Tuesday, January 29, 2019

Chet Wallace Plays Winecoff Piano

Chet Wallace plays a refurbished piano recovered from The Winecoff Hotel.

TBS StoryLine Video 2007

Posted with permission. Back to Winecoff.Org.